Oct 22, 2013

Are You The Reacher Or The Settler?

Are you settling in your relationship?

According to Dean C. Delis, author of The Passion Trap, every relationship has a reacher and a settler.

A reacher is the “one-down” partner who is dating someone who is somewhat out of their league. The settler is the “one-up” partner who could do better, but is choosing not to.

Masculine energy (which is quick to categorize things as cut and dry either/or scenarios) loves being able to think of things through such narrow lenses. Wouldn’t it be so much easier to be able to consider one person in a relationship as the “one-up” partner and the other as the “one-down?”

Feminine energy (which is creative, flexible, and ever-changing) sees the nuance in relationships. No pairing of people should be forever stuck in one way of being.

Men’s self-help (which The Passion Trap‘s limiting definitions falls under) often gravitates towards this overly black and white dichotomy of “this is exactly how things are, with no variation.” In chasing after certainty, subtlety and nuance gets lost.

And honestly, the idea that one partner in any given relationship will eternally be settling sounds pretty depressing.

So here’s my updated, more balanced take on the reacher/settler debate.

Attractive Woman Listening to Her Boyfriend

1. You Reach And Settle In Different Ways

Relationships are multi-faceted. One of you might feel that the other is more physically attractive. Maybe your partner brings more emotional durability to the table. Perhaps you have a lot of direction in life, and your partner benefits from this more than you benefit from hers.

Thanks to the cognitive bias of selective attention, when you decide to believe that you are “the settler” in your relationship, you will pick up feedback from your environment that will reinforce this belief. You will criticize things that your partner does to justify your feelings of superiority.

She accidentally forgets to put away the jar of mayo? It will appear that a horrible transgression has been committed. Her fumbling of a joke’s punch line will seem like the faux pas-iest of faux pas. She leaves her dirty clothes on the floor (and not in the hamper) and it will represent a personal affront to you and your awesomeness.

Get off your high horse, take a look at your relationship through clear eyes, and realize that you both bring value to each other’s lives in different ways.

2. You Take Turns In Each Role

If you are always the reacher and she is always the settler then neither of you are growing.

When you first started dating, you might have felt like you were seeing someone way out of your league. So what did you do? You chose to grow. You wanted to meet her on her level. You sorted your life out, started exercising more, started crushing it in business, and just generally became a more competent and amazing human being.

After a while, she sensed that you were growing and she didn’t want to fall behind. She was inspired by you and your drive.

So what did she do? She followed suit and continued to up the ante.

And just as easily as you could describe this as a reacher/settler swapping of roles, I would attribute this to an alternating divide of comfort and growth phases.

When you are the reacher, you are in a growth phase. You are pushing to be your absolute best.

The word settler seems poisonous to be keeping track in such a competitive frame… let’s go with encourager.

When you are an encourager, you help your partner by supporting them in their growth phase. You see how much work they are putting into their health/wealth/fulfillment and you are on the sidelines cheering as loud as you can.

The truly thriving relationship exists when you can take on both roles as a reacher and an encourager. You are both simultaneously building and advancing yourself, while encouraging your partner to grow.

3. Either Role Is Based On Individual Perspective

Whether you see yourself as the reacher or the settler can also fluctuate on a day-to-day, moment-to-moment basis.

You might both think that you’re the reacher in your relationship on your best days (“I am so lucky to be with such an amazing person”) or, during a heated argument, you might both momentarily think that you’re the settler (“She is so lucky to be with such an amazing person”).

Does The Reacher Settler Debate Have Any Merit?

I believe there is value in the reacher settler model when it forces someone to realize that they are continually dating below their potential.

Being with someone that you feel doesn’t challenge you in any way is not a relationship that is benefiting you or your partner. You will grow to resent her and she will feel like she is walking on egg shells around you. She will take care to not disturb the delicate dynamic between the two of you for fear that you will leave her.

Let her go, and find someone that you feel more appropriately challenges you in becoming the best version of you that ever lived.

Which Are You – The Reacher Or The Settler?

Beliefs are powerful things. Whichever role you assume yourself to be captaining, your environment and relationship will seem to reinforce that.

Would you rather have resentment towards your partner in assuming that you’re too good for her, or be motivated towards constant growth in assuming that you might need to level up in certain areas to match her?

The choice, as always, is yours

.

Dedicated to your success,

Jordan

Ps. This debate was also further popularized by the TV show How I Met Your Mother, so if this all sounds familiar and you haven’t read Delis’s book, this would be why.

Blog

Related

See All
4 Things That Keep Men From Committing To You
Jun 22, 2020
Jordan Gray
4 Things That Keep Men From Committing To You
For a man to place two feet fully into a relationship, he needs to feel that certain key boxes are checked in his life. When they aren’t, he won’t be able to feel a clear “Yes,” which may cause him to feel ambiguous and resistant around committing to a woman. Based on the title of this article, you...
Continue Reading
The Ultimate Guide To Attracting A Partner That Aligns With You
Jul 16, 2014
Jordan Gray
The Ultimate Guide To Attracting A Partner That Aligns With You
As much as my books and blog posts largely focus on how to be the ultimate relationship partner, I get asked by men on a daily basis how to meet and attract a quality relationship in the first place. Without further ado, here is what I have learned through 15 years of serial monogamy. While getting...
Continue Reading
What 100 People Said Their Ideal Love Life Looks Like
Apr 5, 2015
Jordan Gray
What 100 People Said Their Ideal Love Life Looks Like
I recently asked 50 men and 50 women a simple question regarding their ideal love life. I asked them to each complete a single “sentence stem” five times. That sentence stem was “If I were to take full responsibility in my love life…”. Their answers were inspiring, beautiful, heart-warming,...
Continue Reading
How To Love Your Highly Sensitive Partner
Mar 15, 2015
Jordan Gray
How To Love Your Highly Sensitive Partner
I recently received a message from one of my readers that sparked my interest. - “My wife is (what she labels as) a “highly sensitive person” or HSP. Quite often, things that I don’t see as a huge deal can make her go running for shelter for hours on end. I love her to bits and I just want to understand...
Continue Reading
12 Romantic Proposal Ideas For You To Steal
Apr 1, 2021
Jordan Gray
12 Romantic Proposal Ideas For You To Steal
So you’re ready to get down on one knee and tie the knot with the love of your life… Before we get to talking about ways to do it, let me grab my trumpet and set off some confetti cannons… Because that is amazing! (*Cue explosions and marching band*) The fact that you’re at a place in your relationship...
Continue Reading
6 Connection Exercises For Couples To Build Intimacy
Nov 18, 2014
Jordan Gray
6 Connection Exercises For Couples To Build Intimacy
Over the past few years I’ve compiled a collection of connection exercises that have helped couples from all walks of life increase their intimacy and sense of connectedness. The couples that tend to flock towards coaching with me are not people who are on the brink of divorce but people who are already...
Continue Reading